Can't realy agree
đăng bởi Roger B trong Thụy Sĩ diễn đàn
I'm sorry but that's just a bit too much taking the nominal for the real value. Much of what you describe is not a "true" attitude but more a way to make fun of each other. Stereotyping each other is like a national sport, but no one, and I need to know because I'm on of those apparently so despised "Zürcher", really takes the things dead seariously (it's teasing each other, nothing more). You can't realy derive any meaningful conclusion out of that particular phenomenon.
And saying that we define us from what we leave out, while having certainly some currency when it comes to sports or any competition, can certainly not be extended to culture in general. In Switzerland, a lot of things work differently than say in Germany, and on a pure material, countable aspect it might even be safe to say, "better" than in most neighbouring countries, and this gives som of us some pride.
And finaly, I am not all that sure if there really is so much a difference between Switzerland and other countries when it comes to questions of center vs. periphery and majority vs. minority etc. I mean, the Quebecois are also quite fixed on their identity, the Southerners in the US also put a premium on their heritage and last but not least, the Scots don't want to be mistaken for Englishmen... I think we could expand that little list to eternity and beyond.
In my opinion, what this really tells us is that perceived identity really is dependent on the situation you are in. If we go with Amartya Sen, no person has only one identity, we're multi-identical people. To make a somewhat general example: If I am in the US, I am a European, if I am somewhere in Europe, I'm Swiss, if I am in Switzerland I'm a Zürcher and finally to break it further down, if I'm in Zürich I'm an Oberländer. We are multi-layered. We could even expand that to include football clubs, politics or type of food we like. So making general statements about where the Swiss do derive there identity from are quite hard to make, as it depends really on both circumstance and perspective.
Now, my statement might be somewhat off-topic, but I really think one should not put too much currency into the "Kantönligeist" and assorted topics.
Những bài trả lời khác
- Making friends in Switzerland
- ...
- Switzerland
- ...
- Switzerland
- Its really hard to make friends
- You want to get to know Swiss? Learn German!
- Friends in der Schweiz
- Making friends in Switzerland
- Hi
- Du musst lerne Deutsch
- Your husband
- looking for new friends
- poor agostino! :)
- Expat's destiny
- about getting to know the swiss...
- hi
- friends in switzerland
- hey Viktoria
- Oh dear
- Agostino. Questo è relativo.
- Friends in Geneva
- Why is it so hard to make friends in Switzerland??
- Sorry Steven.
- thanks juan
- EN la sierra de Guadarrama.
- Boring Switzerland
- guadarrama la conozco
- Find a place where you can learn German / French - in your case
- Sobre mi zona.
- Friends in Switzerland
- exactly the same
- Switzerland a land of racism, descrimination and stupidity
- About the Swiss
- About the Swiss
- lonesome
- It's most difficult in Zurich
- Bitte echli MITdenke!!!
- @ Benno de Vries
- Viktoria
- Just flicking through these posts
- how is berlin
- zurich
- Berlin is great!
- Thanks for your posts Steven and Dino
- About Switzerland
- Conformity
- It takes time
- I must be very lucky
- How long are you staying?
- now im really angry how swiss are and behave
- you are right jim
- Maybe Zurich is different to Bern?
- hola celia zurich es diferente hi celia zurich is diferent
- celia have you tried to meet people out of your laboral area
- People from work and not from work
- zuri is very diferent,but people are also closed
- Welcome to hell - welcome to Switzerland?
- nothing to add to claudios comment
- When in Switzerland...
- Switzerland is no Mexico
- Move to another country!
- What's the matter
- To Andy
- Come on...
- What?
- Miscegenation
- alright
- Your own theories are based on emotions and not on facts!
- reply
- if you arnt swiss, you arnt good enough
- i need help.
- To Mark
- canuck
- @ mark
- canuck
- Sorry
- The Swiss and their friends
- hi
- Why is it so hard to make friends in Switzerland??
- to Faiz
- Why is it so hard to make friends in Switzerland??
- @ Faiz
- Why is it so hard to make friends in Switzerland??
- @ Faiz
- Why is it so hard to make friends in Switzerland??
- ouch
- Schwiitzertüütsch
- @ Roger and Daniel
- Why is it so hard to make friends in Switzerland??
- Swiss Friends
- @ Canuck
- Can't realy agree
- You're right
- the "kantönligeist"
- @ roger
- german speaker
- Can't agree
- thanks
- no problem
- thanks
- becose they dont want new people or diferent people
- attn. Brian Taylor
- Dear Brian Taylor
- Swiss people are....
- fellow canuck
- hoi!
- :
- good to hear your story
- new in switzerland!!
- hi
- hi back
- the Swiss are very racist . They hate everybody including themeselves
- Yeah..whatever
- Swiss people are boring
- About Switzerland
- @ Jim
- Na, can't do other than disagree
- about switzerland
- Goodevening Maria and Everyone,
- About Switzerland
- Life in Switzerland
- @ alexander, roger and just in general
- Fear of foreigners is one of the reasons...
- A piece of news from World Radio Switzerland
- Switzerland & Racism
- why ???
- To Roger B with respect
- back with respect
- Difficult to integrate with this kind of campains
- I understand but it's a free democracy
- Free democracy promoting racist and xenophobic campains aginst foreigners
- half the country?
- The authorities have to be blamed for their inaction
- of course part of the problem are the authorities
- @ Roger
- a question for roger
- Swiss racism is to blame for everything
- racism in Switzerland
- Mr. Jackson be careful...
- Switzerland explained
- STOP IT
- Mr. Switzerland you be very careful
- Stop it
- To Jim Jakson
- hi
- bout carefulnes
- Foreigners more than ever considered to be criminals!!!
- Na, if you think it's the way you describe, you have not understood the initiative
- This is an ugly racist and xenophobic agenda
- We pet a lost dog, so lets send a smile to the stranger...
- Racisim big time in Switzerland as usual..
- racism in Switzerland
- Here is a good one foe you again from a "foreign" friend in Switzearland
- let's stop about this racisme shit?!
- n
- Check what Human rights web site says about racism in Switzerland
- get the point guys
- hi
- thanks
- racism in Switzerland
- I understand you
- hi dear flo regina
- sorry to hear that
- Even for a swiss guy it's not easy to make friends in Switzerland
- re
- re
- the same
- Yes, it is VERY hard to find friends in this country!!!
- to live in Switzerland
- LOOKING FOR GOLD DEALERS URGENT
- Why is it so hard to make friends in Switzerland??
- Dear Karim
- ok
- I need help
- my opinion
- Seriously?
- Open your heart
- :-O
- MSC STUDENT INQUIRY
- Its really easy to make friends
- Oh yeah?
- great, li lu
- Blaming Swiss
- Riiiight
- Hi
- hello
- Dear Nikko Z.
- O yes!
- Really?
- What to do with a problem named Mariaaaaaa?
- Lmao
- Hello
- Time
- Agrees
- Thanks
- Friends and other things
- PS, forgot to say one last thing...
- Looking for friends
- Reply
- Tonight ????
- Swiss people are haters
- @sonia
- Yeah, right.
- Seldom had such a good laugh...
- I am Spanish
- Not totally hard to find a friends...
- Y ppl not serious in friendhsip from switzerland
- do not agree
- not easy for us
- sei
- still existing the comunity college in Zurich
- The best thing about Switzerland is to leave it!!!
- oh
- For one who said "The best thing about Switzerland is to leave it!"
- Hie
- I don't understand....
- reply to Davor and others
- Its Right!!!
- you can't have one without the other?????
- sidenote
- so stupid jokes
- Get a grip.
- Seriously??
- swiss
- Friends
- Answers?
- Sorry
- you may try a course to make Swiss friends
- racism in Switzerland a concern?
- person who's good ,nice and simple, can find good friends everywhere...
- Swiss direct democracy leads the world
- Whaaat???
- Big time Racism in Switzerland
- Jim, are you OCD?
- .
- Switzerland vs US
- .
- .
- .
- .
- Friendliness Requirement
- agirlin..
- no obligation to be friendly
- Clin, are you a white south african?
- I think that ...
- Are Swiss racist?
- Very true...
- about CH
- MAN I SPENT MY LAST CENT TO BUY YOU A DRINK
- Friends
- Always hard to make new friends
- hmm
- not multicultural
- It is hard everywhere
- I agree but....!
- hey...
- We can meet
- Since 1 year
- Hi
- This one goes to canuck s
- Suche nette Leute weiblich und männlich um zusammen was zu unternehmen
- From the outside
- Why is it so hard to make friends in Switzerland??
- Why is it so hard to make friends in Switzerland?? (40)
- From the outside
- If this thread is so popular since 2008...
- Well they aren't that unfriendly
- Its just another peace of land
- "hosting in Egyptian Home" welcome to hosting in our Egyptian Home in Egypt ..f
- Swiss
- Making friends in switzerland
- Frendship
- Frendship
- Reply
- Hmmmmmm
- Traditional and Conservative
- Making friends in Switzerland